#62 Is ChatGPT Making Me Dumber?


Happy Friday Reader!

I'm writing to you again from my little garage in Venice Beach – the place where my thoughts flow and the AI magic begins.

I just got back from Europe – four weeks of workshops, family, friends, and sea air. One big highlight: sailing by catamaran from Split to Dubrovnik.

Now I’m back in L.A., jet-lagged – with two kids and no school.

And you know how it is: when you’re wide awake at 4 a.m., your thoughts start spinning.

This time, one question just wouldn’t let me go:
Is ChatGPT actually making me – and my kids – dumber?


The MIT Study That Got Me Out of Bed

The trigger was a new study from the MIT Media Lab called “Your Brain on ChatGPT.”

In short:
People who write with ChatGPT are less engaged, have worse memory recall – and are less creative.

At first, I was skeptical.

But then I got honest with myself:
Since I got my iPhone, I barely remember phone numbers or addresses.
I completely rely on tech.

I often don’t even think anymore. If I need something, I just Google it.

And ever since I added ChatGPT & Co. to my toolbox, it's gotten even more intense:
I get help with almost everything – from fixing things to creating content.
And I love what these tools make possible.

But it got me thinking:
What is this doing to my brain over time?
And even more importantly:
What is it doing to the way my kids think?

Have you ever asked yourself that?

I did – and I decided to test myself.


My Citizenship Test – With and Without AI

I recently took the U.S. citizenship test:
100 questions on history, politics, and institutions.

And I didn’t just want to pass – I wanted to understand.

So I went back to the basics:
Flashcards. Repetition. Handwritten notes.

At some point I thought: Who’s going to quiz me?
My husband was too tired after work.
My kids? Too small.

So – I turned to ChatGPT as my quiz coach.

I uploaded the questions as a PDF, wrote a quick prompt, put on my headphones – Walk & Talk style.

At first, it was great.
Then... outdated senators, wrong facts.
If I hadn’t studied beforehand, I would’ve believed it – and learned it wrong.

That was my Aha moment.
From that point on, I was sharper. More critical.
AI isn’t a replacement for my thinking.
It can help me learn and understand – but only if I’ve already taken the time to think for myself.

And that insight came back to me faster than I expected.


My Daughter Wants to Become Taylor Swift – and She Thinks Critically

A few days later, my 7-year-old came to me:

“Mama, I want to write a song. Like Taylor Swift.”

I could’ve used Suno AI and had a song generated in ten seconds.

But I thought back to that Aha moment.
That I only truly learn when I start with my own thoughts – and let AI support later.

So I said:
“Okay – but first, let’s learn how to write a song.”
The AI can help us later – once we’ve got our ideas.”

She grabbed a piece of paper, sat down at the table – and started writing. Totally in her own world.

We listened to songs, broke down choruses, talked about genres.

Only then did we bring in ChatGPT and Suno – as a critical song coach and creative amplifier.

She learned how to ask for feedback, add twists, and understand what makes a great song.

And that evening? She stood in the kitchen with a wooden spoon as a mic, singing her very first song:
"I really feel the beat."

The rest of the family turned dinner into a mini dance party.

Then came her next request: a cover image for her band – “FoxBand.”

We opened ChatGPT.

What did we get?
Muscle-bound foxes in sunglasses. All male.
My daughter just said:
“I want a female fox.”
Then came pink dresses.
“Stereotype,” she said, dryly.

And that led us to a whole conversation about bias, about stereotypes.
About how we can train AI to understand what we actually mean.

With a seven-year-old.

It wasn’t just cute.
It was real, critical thinking – in action.


What I Took Away From All This

It’s not about whether we should use AI – out of fear that it might make us dumber.
It’s about how we use it – so we don’t become mentally lazy.

Or as Ethan Mollick put it in his latest newsletter:
"AI doesn’t damage our brains. But unthinking use can damage our thinking."

I feel the same way.
AI doesn’t harm our brains.
But it can make us comfortable –
if we use it without reflection.
And if we don’t teach our kids to do it better.


My Checklist for Smarter AI Use

And that’s my new approach – for me, and for my kids:

🔹 Think first. Then prompt.
🔹 Write first. Then let AI review.
🔹 Create first. Then expand.
🔹 Analyze first. Then validate.

Your ideas. Your voice. Your values.
AI should amplify you – not replace you.


💬 Now It's Your Turn

How are you using AI to learn – for yourself or with your kids?
What have you noticed?

I’d love to hear your stories.

❤️ from Venice Beach

Simone

Initatorin von Future-Ready Woman

Jede Woche (oder sagen wir… immer dann, wenn ich nicht gerade versuche, 1000 Bälle gleichzeitig zu jonglieren) nehme ich dich mit in meinen bunten Alltag – als Woman in Tech, hands-on Mama und Mensch im ganz normalen Wahnsinn.Ich teile echte KI-Use Cases, Learnings, Fails und Aha-Momente auf meinem Weg zur Future-Ready Woman – Schritt für Schritt.Mit allen Ängsten, Zweifeln und hormonellen Stimmungsschwankungen, die dazugehören, wenn man als Frau in der Perimenopause trotzdem (oder gerade deswegen!) alles vom Leben will.

Read more from Initatorin von Future-Ready Woman
Alt-Text: Eine Frau mit großen runden Brillen und pink geschminkten Lippen küsst einen roten Roboter mit weißem Gesicht und ebenfalls bemalten Lippen. Beide tragen Brillen, was die Szene humorvoll und verspielt wirken lässt. Der Hintergrund ist bunt, und

Happy Saturday Reader! Ich schreibe dir heute wieder aus meiner kleinen Garage in Venice Beach – da, wo meine Gedanken fließen und die KI-Magie beginnt. Meine Kinder sind zurück in der Schule – nach drei Monaten Sommerpause. Es war eine tolle Zeit, aber als Mama und Businessfrau bin ich manchmal echt an meine Grenzen gekommen. Diese Woche hatte ich endlich wieder etwas mehr Raum zum Experimentieren. Und ich wollte ein Problem lösen: Seit dem Upgrade zu ChatGPT-5 klangen meine Antworten nicht...

Ein altes Kinderfoto von Simone Lis am ersten Schultag – mit Zahnlücke, pinkem Hemd und einer bunten Schultüte in der Hand. Ein Moment voller Aufregung und Neugier, der zeigt, wo ihre erste große Lernreise begann – und niemals enden wird.

Happy Saturday Reader! Ich schreibe dir heute wieder aus meiner kleinen Garage in Venice Beach – da, wo meine Gedanken fließen und die KI-Magie beginnt. Diese Woche habe ich mir 2 Tage lang Platz in meinem vollen Kalender geschaufelt und 12h lang die Schulbank in Sachen KI gedrückt – und zwar bei der AI-First Virtual Konferenz von Allie K Miller. Die Konferenz war "high-energy" und "advanced" – und ehrlich gesagt hat mein Kopf sowas von geraucht. Das lag nicht nur am Thema, sondern auch am...

Happy Saturday Reader! I’m writing to you from my little garage in Venice Beach—the place where my thoughts flow and the AI magic begins. And yes, this week was a lot. Experiments. Updates. Opinions everywhere. Did your inbox also explode with “ChatGPT-5” takes—LinkedIn posts, newsletters, YouTube videos? Once you recover from the information overload, you notice the pattern: everyone is declaring what ChatGPT-5 supposedly can (or can’t) do… and the takes start repeating. So I paused, noticed...